It is dangerous to be right in matters on which the established authorities are wrong.
Is it wise to believe too much that you see posted to Facebook? Can you rely on what people say they believe in?
Voltaire has had quite a good week this last week thanks to the madness that we’ve seen in Paris. Several people have posted his saying
“I may disagree with what you have to say, but I’ll defend to the death your right to say it”
Now that’s good, that’s commendable. I entirely approve. But still I wonder. How sincere is this sudden conversion to the principle of “Let a hundred flowers bloom; let a hundred schools of thought contend?”
I thought I’d try an experiment, but at that point I remembered another quote from Voltaire. “I am very fond of truth, but not at all of martyrdom.”
So I’m not trying the experiment, I’m going to ask you, dear reader, to conduct a thought experiment.
Try saying the following things, obviously some of them will be more difficult for some people than for others, but hopefully you’ll be able to sincerely work your way down the list and come out at the end able to cope with them all.
“I quite understand that you might find Tory philosophy offensive and why you would not wish to entertain people who believe in it in your own home.”
“I quite understand that you might find homosexuality offensive and why you would not wish to entertain such people in your own home.”
“When looking back at the miners’ strike one has to accept that the members of the Union of Democratic Mineworkers took a decision which I disagree with but I defend their right to make that decision.”
“Whilst personally I feel that Margaret Thatcher may have been wrong in some of the things she did, this is no reason to demonise her and those who still respect her actions.”
“Whilst I personally have not suffered economically from immigration, I realise that there are those who have and their opinions are just as valid as mine.”
“Ched Evans has served the sentence imposed upon him by a court of law, and thus should be free to take up his profession again.”
And so our American cousins don’t feel left out
“Whilst disagreeing with much in the Democratic/Republican agenda (delete as appropriate) I have no doubt that those in favour of it are decent people, sincere in their beliefs, and whilst they may be wrong, they have the best interests of our country at heart.”
Well can you say them? Are you willing to defend to the death the right of others to say them?
Funnily enough Voltaire said a lot of things
As a reviewer said, “This is a selection of anecdotes about life as a farmer in Cumbria. The writer grew up on his farm, and generations of his family before him farmed the land. You develop a real feeling for the land you are hefted to and this comes across in these stories. We hear of the cattle, the sheep, his succession of working dogs, the weather and the neighbours, in an amusing and chatty style as the snippets of Jim Webster’s countryman’s wisdom fall gently. I love this collection.”